On Nov. 25, a federal-level appeals court ruled in a 2-1 decision that, for now, Florida can enforce a law limiting children’s access to certain social media platforms. The law prevents teens aged 15 and under from creating social media accounts without parental consent on popular platforms such as Snapchat, Instagram, and YouTube. 

Following this ruling, many, including adults and teens, have voiced their opinions. Some argue that the measures violate First Amendment rights, limiting numerous age demographics besides teens. Others applaud the action taken to protect children on social media.

This decision affects high school students especially, even those above the age requirement. Social media serves as a platform for communication, news, and community, and this law threatens access to these features. The question is, however, whether teen-based online communities should be prioritized over the precaution of safety. As the law is enforced, the conversation of constitutionality versus children’s mental health continues.

“When I was younger, social media made me so much more comfortable talking to others. I think it changed who I am today. I don’t want them to take that away from the kids younger than me.” – Dev Gupta, sophomore

“I kind of think that it’s smart to put some controls on the internet. There are so many weird people online nowadays, and even those above 14 can make stupid decisions.” – Axel De la Vega, junior

“I think maybe they can put some controls on the social media access of minors, but they shouldn’t be so strict and restrictive about it. Social media is so important nowadays; it could make these kids feel left out.” – Jiannah Garcia, junior

“Although there are dangers online, I know that I love being on my phone; I really don’t like limits being put on me. It feels like they have too much control.” – Eshan Yousuf, sophomore

“Honestly, I don’t think kids should even be on social media. This law would make sure they don’t find loopholes to get where they shouldn’t be.” – Alyssa Gomez, sophomore

“Even though I’m older than the age limit, I think this is a part of a bigger conversation of censoring. Social media is such a good way to connect with people and express feelings, and taking that away could harm and isolate kids.” – Mariana Vides-Mendez, junior

“Well, there have always been age limits on social media. They are just enforcing it more now. I’m above the age limit, but if I were 14, I would be so mad.” – Aaron Sorensen, sophomore

“I know that I will be so annoyed about this if they really enforce it. I am not a kid, and I think I’m capable of being safe on the internet.” – Kayleigh Willoughby, freshman